Adnan Syed asks Maryland Supreme Court docket to overview reduced court’s ruling that reversed his vacated murder conviction


Adnan Syed, the man who invested far more than two decades driving bars for the 1999 killing of ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, asked the Maryland Supreme Court docket on Wednesday to critique a reduce court’s determination that reversed his vacated conviction, in accordance to court files.

The movement, which was filed by his legal professional to the state’s best court docket, seeks an evaluation of numerous variables in the significant-profile case, which was showcased in the landmark podcast “Serial.”

1 of these features worries Lee’s brother’s narrative that he was not presented enough notice about a hearing very last 12 months, which in the end resulted in a decide vacating Syed’s murder conviction and him currently being introduced.

In March, a state appellate court reinstated Syed’s conviction following ruling that a decreased court docket had violated the rights of Lee’s brother, Younger Lee, to show up at the listening to.

In the meantime, Syed’s attorneys argue the victim’s brother experienced confirmed he would show up at the hearing via Zoom.

“Almost immediately subsequent a scheduling meeting on September 16, the Condition emailed Mr. Lee to notify him that the hearing would be held on September 19,” the movement states.

“Because the listening to would be in-individual, the Condition informed Mr. Lee that he would be offered a Zoom hyperlink so that he and his spouse and children would have the option of attending remotely,” in accordance to the submitting.

Then, when the state’s agent didn’t obtain a reaction from the victim’s brother immediately after two days, “she arrived at out to him by textual content message to ensure that he experienced gained her electronic mail and was informed of the listening to.

“Mr. Lee acknowledged receipt of the e-mail and mentioned that he would be becoming a member of by Zoom,” the filing ongoing.

Syed’s “innocence is not at challenge, but his legal rights as a defendant and independence as an exoneree are straight impacted by the Appellate Court docket of Maryland’s decision,” Syed’s attorney, Erica Suter, explained in a assertion.

“Beyond the import of these proceedings to Adnan and his household, the troubles lifted have broader implications for our complete lawful procedure, most notably the authority of the Point out to dismiss a circumstance, the part of victims’ representatives in proceedings to redress unjust convictions, and the limits placed on judges’ discretion to benefit from distant interaction solutions like Zoom,” Suter extra. “We hope that the Supreme Courtroom will take into account these vital issues of to start with impact.”

An lawyer for the relatives of Hae Min Lee, David Sanford, responded to the submitting.

“The Appellate Court docket of Maryland identified that victims in the state of Maryland have rights. We are self-assured that the Maryland Supreme Courtroom will also recognize these legal rights and hold that victims may perhaps not only acquire notice of and go to a vacatur listening to, but also meaningfully participate in that hearing.”

Attorneys for Hae Min Lee’s family requested the court docket in February to redo the listening to that vacated Syed’s conviction.

The decision to vacate Syed’s conviction arrived practically eight yrs following the podcast dug into the case and lifted issues about the conviction and Syed’s authorized representation.

In conveying her choice to vacate, Baltimore City Circuit Decide Melissa Phinn cited material in the state investigation that was not properly turned in excess of to defense lawyers, as well as the existence of two suspects who may have been improperly cleared as portion of the investigation.

Leave a Reply